- Pardon - 6 Mar 1815
- Patience Howard - 28 Apr 1809
- Patience Howard - 10 Dec 1837, Harwich, MA
- Paul Carroll - 31 Mar 1925, Belden, NE
- Permelia - 22 Oct 1811
- Permelia - c1858, IA
- Perry - 7 Oct 1759, Pomfret, CT [son]
- Perry Curtis - c1847, Hancock Co., KY ["Curtis"]
- Peter - c1831
- Phebe - c1760?, Harvard, MA
- Phebe - 8 Jul 1783
- Phebe - 20 Apr 1807; d 24 Oct 1811
- Phebe - Nov 1822; "may have died young"
- Phebe Ann - c1845; d 27 Mar 1849, ae 4
- Phebe Bessie - 1885; d 11 Nov 1885
- Phianda L. - c1841
- Phidelia - c1813 [1804/10 or c1814] ["Philena"]
- Philena - 13 Feb 1787, [Woodstock?], CT
- Philitta - /"Vilesta" , c1847, VT [census]
- Pliny - c1795
- Prentice - c1847 [census]
- Prescott F. - c1827
- Priscilla - 7 Sep 1803
- Prudence - 4 Oct 1786, Athol, MA
- Prudence - 2 Jun 1848; d 17 Jul 1849