Listed are the years in which the Pastors were appointed. The Annual Conference met mostly in April through 1857; mostly in March through 1933; in September through 1964; and in June since 1965.
 

1766-67	First Societies established in New York City, Maryland, and Philadelphia.
1764f	John Earley , Thomas Taper, Jesse Chew.
1767-71	Edward Evans (Mt. Royal/Clarksboro)
1769f	Joseph Pilmoor, Richard Boardman (from England)
1771f	Francis Asbury, Richard Wright, Abraham Whitworth.
1773	Note: First American Methodist Conference
	John King, Phillip Gatch
1774	Phillip Ebert
1775	William Duke, John King, Daniel Ruff
	"New Jersey" Circuit of Philadelphia Conference
1776	Robert Lindsay, John Cooper (d.1789)
1777	Henry Kennedy, Thomas McClure
1778	Daniel Ruff, Benjamin Abbott did considerable work. (d.1796)
1779	Phillip Cox, Joshua Dudley, Daniel Ruff
1780	William Gill (d.1789), John James, Richard Garretson
	"West Jersey Circuit"
1781	Caleb Pedicord (d.1785), James O. Cromwell, Joseph Everett
1782	Joshua Dudlay, Richard Ivy
1783	Woolman Hickson (d.1788), John Magary
1784	Samuel Rowe, William Partridge, John Fidler
1785	William Phoebus, Robert Sparks, Thomas Ware (1758-1842) On trial 1784.
1786	Jacob Brush, John Simmons, Jacob Lurton
1787	Robert Cann, John McClasky, John Milburne
	"Salem Circuit" All South Jersey
1788	Nathaniel B. Mills, John Cooper, Joseph Cromwell
1789	Simon Pyle, Jethro Johnson, Sylvester Hutchinson
	"Bethel Circuit" Camden, Gloucester, Atlantic Counties
1790	Robert Cann, William Jackson
1791	James O. Cromwell
1792	Robert Cann, Levi Rogers
1793	Gamaliel Bailey, Shadrack Bostwick
1794	Benjamin Fisler (1769-1854) M.D. married Catherine Murphy (9 children). Settled in Port Elizabeth.
1795	Benjamin Fisler, Robert Searle
1796	John Ragan, Andrew Turck
1797-98	Richard Sneath, R. Hutchinson
1799	Zenas Conger, Levine Moore
1800	Thomas Everard, John Stewart
1801	Richard Swain, Samuel Rose
1802	Samuel Thomas, Benjamin Iliff
	"Gloucester Circuit" (was Bethel)
1803	Benjamin Iliff, Daniel Higley
1804	David Dunham, Asa Smith
1805	Joseph Totten, William Bishop
1806-07	Nathan Swain, Saumel Budd
1808 (more)	Richard Sneath, W. S. Fisher
1809	Thomas Dunn, Charles Reed
1810	Peter Vannest, J. Osborn, Thomas Davis
1811	John Fox, John Furman
1812	John Fox, John Townsend
1813	Daniel Ireland, William Smith (1802 on trial; d.1854 Long Branch)
1814	John Woolson, Edward Stout (1785-1859) On trial 1814.
1815	Amos C. Moore, Daniel Fidler (1771-1842). On trial 1789.
1816	Amos C. Moore , John J. Walker (1764-1849). On trial 1802.
1817	Solomon Sharp, William Smith
1818	Peter Vannest, James Long (1788 Ire.-1863 Mer. Co.) On trial 1820.
1819	Thomas Davis, David Bartine – on trial 1832, transferred to Newark 1870.
1820	David Bartine, Richard W. Petherbridge (1792 Phila.-1861 Pemb.) On trial 1816. P. Elder 3 years. Left widow and several children.
1821	Richard W. Petherbridge, Edward Stout (1785-1859). On trial 1814. Pastor 46 years.
1822	Edward Stout, David Dailey
1823	James Moore, Waters Burrows – on trial 1816. Transferred to Newark 1857.
1824 (more)	Waters Burrows, William Lummis (b.1776 P. Neck – d.1843 Glou. Co.) 1811 on trial. Received 5000 members. Left widow and 4 children. Son Fletcher a Trav. Min.
1825-26	John Woolson, Eliphalet Reed
1827	William Lummis, Edward Page (1787 Burl. Co. – 1866). On trial 1817. Did 3041 Baptisms.
1828	Edward Page, J. Iliff
1829	Jacob Gruber, Richard M. Greenbank
1830	Richard M. Greenbank, William Williams – On trial 1810. Transferred to Philadelphia 1838.
1831	William Williams, Sedgwick Rusling (1799 NNJ – 1876 Rahway). On trial 1827. Married Electa Cummings.
1832	John Henry, Jacob Loudenslager (1793 Glo. Co. – 1871 Pauls.). On trial 1832.
1833	Edward Stout, a supply.
1834-35	William Lummis, John F. Crouch (b.1804 MD–d.1852 Glass.) 1833 on trial.
1836	James Long Thomas Christopher (1806-1850). On trial 1834.
	"New Jersey Conference" Formed
1837-38	James Long, John W. McDougall, (1812 Mor. Co. – 1882). On trial 1833. Pastor 42 years; Abram Owen (1800-1875). On trial 1836.
1839	Edward Stout, George Jennings – on trial 1838. Located 1845.
1840	George Jennings, Joseph J. Sleeper (1793 Vinc.-1873 Pemb). On trial 1837.
1841	Joseph. J. Sleeper, Benjamin N. Reed – on trial 1835. Located 1855.
1842	Thomas Christopher, Abram K. Street (1807-1898). On trial 1831. 1834 m. Elizabeth Robertson. Was P. Elder.
1843	Joseph Gaskill (1817 SNJ-1903 Trent.). On trial 1842. Located 1856.
	Joseph Atwood (1804 Tuck.-1886 Cam./Tuck.). On trial 1837. 1851 m. Abigail Turner (1807-1876 Trent.).
1844	Joseph Atwood , John Fort (1816 Pemb.-1875 Blkwd.). 1838 m. Elizabeth Emley (2 ch.) On trial 1843.
	(Pittsgrove off—Friendship, Monroe & Olivet)
1845	John Fort, Nathaniel Chew - on trial 1829. Located 1850.
1846	William A. Brooks (1810 Phila.-1868 C. May Co.). On trial 1836. Wife Anna (3 ch.);
	David Duffell (1801 Cam.-1884 Clay.). On trial 1839.
1847	David Duffell, Abraham I. J. Truitt – on trial 1838. Located 1854.
1848	Abraham I. J. Truitt, Bromwell Andrews – on trial 1829. Transferred to Newark 1858.
1849	Bromwell Andrews, Noah Edwards (1809 Bargt.-1889 Hadd.). 1832 m1 Hannah J. Downs (d.1836 – 2 sons). On trial 1839. m2 P. Hartshorn (3 daughters).
1850	Abraham Gearheart (b.1788 Hun. Co.-d.1854 Tuck.) On trial 1829; Noah Edwards
1851	Abraham Gearheart, Dayton F. Reed – on trial 1850. Transferred to Newark 1857.
1852-53 (more)	James J. White (1816 Phila-1873). On trial 1838. 1841 m. Margaret Willits of W. Ck. (3 ch.), Civil War chaplain. Had received 2000 members.
	Levi J. Rhoads (1808 PA-1871 S. River). Local Preacher 1846.
	(Willow Grove Circuit split off—Willow Grove, Union Grove, Malaga)
1854-55	Joseph C. Summerill (1821 P.Grove-1882). On trial 1844. 1849 m. Sarah J. Vaneman (6 ch.).
	Charles W. Heisley (1826-1916 Cranberry). On trial 1853. Lived to age 90.
1856-57	Samuel M. Hudson (1826 Wbry.-1903 Pit.). 1849 m. Mary Jester. On trial 1852. Married 2 more times.
	Albert Matthews (1825 Dias Ck.-1906 Vnld.). 1847 m. Emily Leaming (5 ch.). On trial 1856.
1858	Hamilton S. Norris (1819 Phila.-1904 C. May Co.). 1840 m. Mary Jane Thomas. 1855 on trial.
	John P. Connelly (1828 Phila.-1905 Palmyra). On trial 1855. 1858 m. Mary Taylor (3 ch.)
1859	Hamilton S. Norris; Samuel Chattin  (1837 NYC-1903 Tuck.). On trial 1861.
1860 (more)	Edwin Waters (1824 Wdtn.-1910).On trial 1850. 3 ch.
	Albert Atwood – on trial 1858. Transferred to Oregon 1874.
1861	Edwin Waters, Edward T. Marks – on trial 1859. Discontinued 1862.
1862	William C Stockton (1820 PA-1902 Vnld.). 1842 m. Mary Brusster. On trial 1852. Civil War chaplain. 1875 Conf. evangelist. m2 Sarah E. Chancey; plus a supply pastor.
1862½	Julius Wilcox – a Local Preacher 1/2 year.
	Joseph H. Mickle (1841-Mauricetown-1896). On trial 1863. m. Hannah Souder (1 ch.).
1863-64	Lucius O. Manchester (1834 Conn.-1909 DE). 1855 m. Anna Bray (2 ch). On trial 1863. Pastor 44 yrs.
	(Union off - Unionville/Aura, Mt. Pleasant/Richwood, Monroeville, Franklinville)
1865-66 (more)	Matthias H. Shimp (1830 P.Grove-1908 Magnolia). 1856 on trial. 1859 m. Margaret Woodruf (5 ch.)
	(Gloucester Circuit - Porchtown, Lake, Piney Hollow, Friendship-Landisville)
1867	S. Wesley Lake (1842 Plvl.-1917 O.City). 1864 m. Mary Scull (6 ch.). On trial 1867.
1868-69	John L. Souder (1828 P.Eliz.-1899 Cam.) On trial 1857. 1859 m. Carrie Powell.
1870-71	Ezekiel C. Hancock (1839-1916). 1862 m. Emma Githens (3 ch.). On trial 1866.
1872-73	John Warthman (1837 Phila.-1904). Transferred to Tennessee 1855.
1874	Peter Y. Calder (1814 NYC-1900 Palmyra). 1838 m. Hannah Justice (1 ch.). On trial 1853.
1875-76	Edwin F. Moore (1848 Rahway-1877 H.Sq.). 1870 on trial. 1872 m. Emma Rogers.
1877-78	Caleb A. Malsbury (d.c.1895). On trial 1856. Transferred to Newark 1857-65; 1866 back to N.J.
1879	John L. Nelson – on trial 1876. Trans. to Troy 1897.
1880-82	John Brown Whitton (1845 Phila.-1927 Palmyra). 1869 m. Sadie Countess (5 ch.). On trial 1886. Was P. Elder. Son – Rev. Charles D. Whitton.
1883	William E. Blackiston (1851 DE-1931 O.Grove). 1879 m. Annie Mills. 1882 on trial.
	(Gloucester Circuit – add Plainville)
1884	James O. R. Corliss (1851 Salem-1932 Clermont). 1882 m. Harriet Richman (4 ch.); also on trial.
1885	Joseph Gray Edwards (1851 P. Eliz.-1923 Trent.). 1877 m. Elisha Cox (4 ch.) Pastor 38 years.
1886	No Gloucester Circuit
	"Harmony Circuit"
	R. Brooks Robbins – Friendship, Piney Hollow, Plainville (Next year called Harmony Circuit) Robbins – Local Preacher from Pt. Norris. 1886 and 1887 supply pastor.
	Wilber B. Nobles – Malaga, Lake. Nobles – on trial 1885, located 1900.
	John P. Connelly – (Willow Grove, Union Grove, Porchtown, N. Vineland, Forest Grove, Pleasantville)
1887	R. Brooks Robbins
1888-89	Lewis N. Clark (1833-1909 Porch.) On trial 1858.
1890	Samuel L. Johnson - Local Preacher from Woodruff (1902 at Aura).
	"Richland Circuit"
1891 (more)	John G. Clark (Richland and Friendship). Local Preacher from Forest Grove.
1892	Frank Coleman – Local Preacher from Deerfield/Aldine.
	"Friendship Circuit"
1893-96 (more)	Abram Jaggers (add Richland to Harmony Circuit) He a Local Preacher from Piney Hollow.
1896½	Jesse A. Casto (1871 At.Co.-1903 Centerton). 1901 on trial. Left widow & 3 children.
1897	Thomas Huss (1867 N.Egypt-1958 O.Grove Home) (Minotola, Friendship)
1898-00 (more)	Charles H. Barnes (Bgtn.-1914). Became an Evangelist.
	(1899 Richland & Newtonville Circuit created)
1901	George H. VanNote (1860 Oc.Co-1930 W.Farms). 1879 m. Helen Hurley. 1896 moved to Chatsworth —started meetings in empty Presbyterian church. 1916 transferred to M.P. then back to NJ Conference.
	(Friendship, Richland, Newtonville)
1902-3	Jacob S. Smallwood (1874 Quinton-1959). 1907 m. Bessie Jenkins.
1904	Charles Henry DuBois – 1902 Supply, 1911 on trial, 1914 discontinued. 1920 supply at Newfield.
1905-6	Robert Newton Aspinwall, Jr. (1877 Egg. H.-1924 Columbus). 1900 m. Elizabeth Drape (3 ch.) On trial 1906.
1907	David D. Fisler – On trial 1883, supernum 1899, then supply pastor.
1908-10 (more)	Richard D. Smith – 1902f supply from Port Elizabeth
1911-14	William H. McKaig – supply pastor from Woodruff.
1915	Edward B. Campbell – supply from Millville and Minotola.
1916	J. S. Boetaman – supply pastor
1916½-17	Thomas Hess – supply from Clermont, Halyville.
	"Harmony Circuit"
1918	Elmer Joseph Biggs (1885 Mlvl.-1926 Mlvl.). m. Elizabeth Taylor (d.1914, 3 ch.). 1921 on trial. m2 Mary Reeder (1 ch.).
	(Friendship, Piney Hollow, Plainville)
1919	P. S. Sampson – supply from Millville. 1881 m. Rachel Bishop (d.1925). 1930 to Ocean Grove.
1919½	W. R. Coleman
1920	Henry Frank Parker (1885 Tuck.-1926 Plvl.). 1881 m. Cora Hand (Tuck.–1 ch.). On trial 1890.
	(Friendship, Richland)
1921-22	Mark L. Kears – Local Preacher from Vineland. Supply 1921-22.
1923-24	Frank B. Chard – Local Preacher from Millville. Supply.
1925-26	P. S. Sampson
	(Friendship, Richland, Newtonville)
1927	Leolin R. Howell – Supply from Millville
	"Richland Circuit" (Richland, Friendship, Newtonville)
1928-29	Leolin R. Howell
1930-32 (more)	Clarence S. Reeves – Supply from Millville.
	"Newtonville Circuit" (Friendship, Newtonville)
1933	Clarence S. Reeves
1934	Howard Shoemaker – Part-time supply.
	"Minotola Parish" (Friendship, Piney Hollow, Newtonville, Richland and Minotola)
1935	Howard Shoemaker – A part-time supply. Asst. – John Peterson, part-time supply. from Salem
	(Richland discontinued)
1936-40 (more)	Howard Shoemaker and John Peterson
	(Newtonville Circuit)
	"Harmony Circuit" (Friendship, Piney Hollow, Newtonville)
1941-44 (more)	Howard Shoemaker
1945-47 (more)	Harold Dunn (1902 OH-1974 Wdtn.). M. Beatrice Welch (d.1981 SD/Wdtn.-3 ch.). Local Preacher 1941-73.
	"Minotola Circuit"
1948 (more)	Harold Dunn
	"Minotola & Harmony" (Minotola, Forest Grove, Friendship, Newtonville, Piney Hollow)
1949-50 (more)	John Lathrop Herr (1903 PA-1968 Fdsp.). M. Margaret Allen; m2 Edith Powell. He started with M.P. church, then 1939 the Methodist churches.
1951-52	Joseph M. Scott - Student supply.
	‘52 Asst. Archie Shull (1907 P.Norris-1985 Bgtn.) Part time supply from Newfield. 1926 m. Verna Gandy (2 ch.).
1953	Jack Stevenson – Student supply.
1953½-55	Raymond Gruezke, (1924 MI-1975 Oakhurst/Pit.) 1953 m . Ethel Anderson (4 ch.)
	Asst. A. Shull
1956	Paul Pedrick – Student supply
	Asst. William Boyd – Part time supply from Millville
1957-61 (more)	Harold Coles – supply
	(Minotola, Forest Grove, Friendship) (1961 Newtonville discontinued)
1962-64 (more)	Joseph A. Kickasola – Student supply.
1965-69 (more)	Louis Kickasola – supply pastor (Father of Joseph A.)
1968	Forest Grove discontinued.
1969	Assistant Carl Vaughn.
1970-74½	Charles Rumont Sweeten (1894 Cam.-1988 Cin.). 1916 m. Sarah Blose ( 2 ch.) On trial 1923.
	(Friendship alone)
1974½-78½	Evan Chester Pedrick (1910 Hdvl.-1979 Nfld./Fdsp.). Was converted at Friendship at age 11. 1930 m. Ruth Howell. First supply Centre Grove 1930.
1978½-90 (more)	Milton S. Collins. Served full-time 1949-78 (d. 1998).
1991	Clyde A. Phillips – Local Preacher 1967 Nfld. Willow Grove 1970-76.
1991½-93	John B. Mitchell, Jr.– Local Preacher with Newfield UMC. Retired from Bell Telephone.
1994	William G. Chew – Local Preacher. Married to Ann (2 ch.). Also serving Elwood UMC.
1995-97 (more)	Charles R. Gebhardt – Local Preacher. Married to Sally. Retired from AT&T.
1998 (more)	Howard L. Cassaday (b.1924 Bgtn.) 1948 m. Grace Rathbone. 1961 part-time pastor. 1969 Student Pastor. 1989 retired.